Oley's Menu

Appetizers | Salad | Oven Baked Subs | Pizza Rolls | Specialty Pizzas | Italian Dinners | Children's Menu | Desserts


Only the Freshest Ingredients

We are proud of our commitment to quality – from our Family to yours. We use only the best 100% all-natural Wisconsin cheese (over 1,000 pounds a week!) and grate it fresh in store daily to make our Secret Oley’s Four-Cheese Blend. We accept only the highest quality fresh vegetables and ingredients, and prep them in-house to ensure the freshest taste for you. We’ll never sacrifice our quality over cost. Oley's vow in 1980 was to bring to YOUR table the Purest, Finest, Freshest, and most "Naturale" pizza pie in the business. That vow has not changed in over 30 years! Order now and experience the quality that makes the Original Oley’s pizza the BEST!

Download our menu in PDF format.


House Salad

Sub Sandwiches

All subs are served on golden Italian bread and baked to perfection!

Whole Sub $9.99 / Half $6.79

Oley's Pizza Rolls

Tomato sauce, cheese, choice ingredients.

Oley's Specialty Pizzas

We are FAMOUS for our Double Crust Pizza. Oley's FAMOUS Double-Crust. Two thin crusts stuffed with loads of our Secret Cheese Blend, topped with sauce, your favorite ingredients, then MORE cheese & baked to perfection.

Pizza Price Chart

The Original Single Crust Style: Small Medium Large X-Large
Cheese Only $8.35 $11.95 $16.35 $21.35
Additional Toppings $0.90 $1.25 $1.70 $2.20
Specialty Pizzas (listed below) $11.30 $16.25 $22.15 $28.90
Oley's Famous Double Crust Stuffed Style Small Medium Large X-Large "BIG TEN"
Cheese Only $8.85 $13.90 $19.95 $27.15 $35.50
Additional Toppings $0.55 $0.90 $1.25 $1.70 $2.20
Specialty Pizzas (listed below) $10.70 $16.85 $24.20 $33.05 $42.95

Oley's Deluxe

Tomato sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, cheese.


Tomato & alfredo sauce, mild banana peppers, spinach, tomatoes, chicken, cheese

The Californian

Spinach artichoke cream sauce, cheese, tomatoes, chicken, feta cheese

Meat Lovers

Tomato sauce hamburger, Italian sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, cheese

Pepperoni Lovers

Tomato sauce, cheese, pepperoni, pepato pepperoni


Marinara sauce, roasted garlic, freh mozzarella, tomatoes, parmesan, basil


Tomato sauce, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, green olives, black olives, tomatoes, cheese

Additional Topping choices:
Veggies: mushrooms - green peppers - onions - tomatoes - spinach - basil - roasted garlic - green olives - black olives - hot giardiniera - mild peppers - pineapple
Meat: Italian sausage - pepperoni - hamburger - meatballs - bacon - chicken - ham - salami - capicola - steak - mild sausage - pepatos - anchovies

Italian Dinners

Includes - Dinner Salad & two breadsticks.


Lasagna noodles, ricotta, cheese, meat sauce, basil & parmesan

Baked Mostaccioli$12.99

Penne noodles, marinara sauce, ricotta, cheese blend, basil & parmesan

Children's Menu

Cheesy Macaroni$4.99

Oley's homemade Macaroni & cheese served with one breadstick.

Chicken Fingers$4.99

Baked breaded chicken strips served with a side of applesauce & potato chips.




Purple Mountain - fresh baked cheesecake